parallax background


I Love Lucy’s Diamonds and Gold is located in the Commack Jewelry Exchange. The owner, Andrew is a Master Bench Jeweler, diamond setter and designer. All the beautiful pieces in the jewelry cases are hand-picked by Andrew, including a wide variety of 14 kt yellow and white gold diamonds as well as precious stone pieces along with various different watches from brands such as Bulova, Citizen, Seiko, Michele Watches and Movado.



  • Michelle F.
    My family has been using Andy at I Love Lucy for 20+ years for basic jewelry needs, so of course when it was time for our wedding I ensured my now husband that all must go through there. Andy helped to restore my grandmother’s engagement ring for me to have and wear with pride. He ensured that the diamond was safe by adding prongs and spruced it up to look brand new, without losing its vintage charm. When looking for a band, I wanted something simple, yet unique, and couldn’t find exactly what I was hoping to in his display. When I described my taste, he shared the insert that was absolutely perfect for me. My husband also wanted a simple band, and Andy’s staff assisted him in selecting the one that was for him. I can’t say enough about Andy’s customer service.
    Michelle F.
  • Melissa W.
    Great customer service, very knowledgeable and quality repairs! I would not go anywhere else!
    Melissa W.
  • Don C.
    They provide excellent service for a very fair price. Honest! I highly recommend them.
    Don C.
  • Danielle B.
    I’ve been going to Andy for years and love the service received. He’s wonderful for necklaces, rings, repairs, and diamonds. Beautiful tennis bracelets. Custom work as well. We recently got our wedding bands from him. Highly recommend.
    Danielle B.
  • Cheryl C.
    I love︎ I Love Lucy's Diamonds and Gold. Great customer service (the nicest people-Andy & staff!). Nice selection of items-so many earring choices for our 5 Y.O. My watch order came in super quickly!
    Cheryl C.